You’ve just received your brand new cellphone. Maybe you upgraded through your mobile provider, took advantage of a promotion, or finally replaced that old phone you’ve been using for years.
Everything seems perfectly normal.
Then, a few days later, your phone rings.
The caller says they’re from your cellphone provider. There’s been a mistake with your order, they explain. Apparently, you were sent the wrong phone, and they need you to return it.
No problem, right? They’ll even email you a prepaid shipping label so returning it won’t cost you anything.
But here’s the catch: that phone isn’t going back to your cellphone company. It’s going straight to a scammer.
And you could end up without your new phone while still being responsible for paying for it.
It’s Already Happening Here in Nanaimo
In September 2026, Nanaimo RCMP warned residents about a scam targeting people who had recently received new cellphones through legitimate service providers.
According to police, several residents reported receiving calls from individuals pretending to represent their cellphone company.
The callers claimed the wrong device had been shipped and instructed customers to return it using prepaid shipping labels sent by email.
Unfortunately, those shipping labels directed the phones to private addresses or mail drops rather than the actual cellphone providers.
By the time victims discovered what had happened, their phones were gone.
Similar scams have also been reported elsewhere on Vancouver Island, with West Shore RCMP issuing another warning in October.
Here’s What Makes This Scam Especially Sneaky
Many scams start with something suspicious: an unexpected prize, an unusual payment request, or an offer that sounds too good to be true.
This one is different.
You really did order a phone. You really did receive it. And the person calling may know details about your purchase.
That last part is especially concerning.
Nanaimo RCMP reported that victims said the scammers appeared to know information about their recent cellphone purchases and deliveries.
Police haven’t established how the fraudsters obtained those details.
But knowing something about your order doesn’t prove someone works for your cellphone provider.
That’s an important distinction, because we’re naturally more inclined to trust someone who seems familiar with a purchase we’ve actually made.
The Shipping Label Is Where the Trick Happens
A prepaid return label might seem reassuring. After all, why would a scammer offer to cover the shipping?
Because the shipping label determines where your phone actually goes.
You might believe you’re returning the device to your cellphone provider when, in reality, the label directs it somewhere entirely different.
And here’s another complication.
Many smartphones are purchased through monthly financing arrangements. Returning a phone to a scammer doesn’t cancel the financing agreement with your provider.
You could be left explaining why your phone is missing while still having payments due.
Three Things to Check Before Returning Any Phone
If someone contacts you unexpectedly about returning a cellphone, don’t rush to package it up.
1. Contact your cellphone provider yourself.
Use the telephone number printed on your bill, the provider’s official website, or its mobile app.
Don’t rely on the number supplied by the person who called you.
2. Confirm that a return is actually required.
Ask your provider whether there’s a problem with your order and whether they’ve issued a return request.
If the request is genuine, they should be able to confirm it through their own records.
3. Verify the return instructions and shipping address.
Don’t assume a prepaid shipping label is legitimate simply because it looks professional.
Confirm the destination directly with your provider before sending anything.
And don’t forget: even if a caller knows your name, phone model, or order details, that doesn’t automatically make them trustworthy.
What If You’ve Already Sent the Phone?
If you suspect you’ve mailed your new cellphone to a scammer, act as quickly as possible.
Contact your cellphone provider and explain what happened. Ask them to review your account, investigate the return, and advise you about any outstanding device payments.
Contact the shipping company as well. Depending on the shipment’s status, they may be able to help intercept or redirect the package, although there’s no guarantee.
Keep copies of the shipping label, tracking number, emails, and any other communications.
You should also report the incident to your local police and the Canadian Anti-Fraud Centre.
Nanaimo residents can contact the Nanaimo RCMP non-emergency line at 250-754-2345.
If you shared account passwords or financial information, take steps to secure those accounts immediately.
A Real Purchase Doesn’t Guarantee a Real Phone Call
The lesson from this scam is surprisingly simple.
Just because someone contacts you about something that actually happened doesn’t mean they’re who they claim to be.
Whether it’s a cellphone delivery, an online purchase, or a billing problem, independently verifying an unexpected request is always worth the extra few minutes.
At Your Tech Neighbour, we help Nanaimo seniors recognize suspicious phone calls, emails, and messages before they become costly mistakes.
Our Scam Protection service provides a trusted second opinion when something doesn’t seem quite right.
And if you’ve received a suspicious message and aren’t sure what to do, our guide, What to Do If You Think Something Is a Scam, is a good place to start.
Before you click. Before you answer. Before you pay. Before you panic.
Sources and further reading:
